Wildthorn – A Spoiler Free Review

tumblr_m7mruxa5981rs218bo1_400

Photo courtesy of viola-goes-to-hollywood on tumblr

Book: Wildthorn

Author: Jane England

Age Group: Young Adult

Genre: Romance, Historical Fiction, Drama, Adventure, LGBT+, Feminist

Rating: 3.5/5

Let me start off this review by saying if you’re opposed to LGBT+ stop reading now. You won’t enjoy this book at all, even if you enjoyed The Perks of Being a Wallflower. If you are okay with LGBT+ expect a great summer YA read.

First off there is a severe lack of imagery of this book! Tumblr, dA and general Google searches brought up nothing. I’m ashamed to be honest. So instead you guys get some photographs from the victorian era of some lovely lesbian ladies. Why this book? I was actually looking for the next in the Tiger’s Curse series when it caught my eye on the bookshelf at the library. A corset lacing on the front of a YA novel called Wildthorn with the tagline… “Treachery locks her away. Love is the key.” I was hooked line and sinker and picked it up. For those of you who follow me on tumblr you know I was torn between reading The Ocean at the End of the Lane or Wildthorn (I will read both I was just torn about order.) I decided to read Wildthorn. The first day I went through the first 120 pages, mostly full of an intermixing of flashbacks and current setting and events. After the first day though, my reading slowed down and it ended up taking me exactly a week to finish, not too shabby for 350 pages. It’s a page turner indeed and often hard to put down in between scenes. It’s broken into three major story “arcs” easily broken down by England into three major parts with an epilogue. The actual narrative is a flip-flop between flashbacks in bold and current setting and events. The flashbacks add continuously to the story as it evolves, but you don’t get the full story, only hints of it, until part three when it’s all revealed.

Wildthorn follows a 17-year old girl who is unconventional for her Victorian Era. She wants to be a doctor and in fact a new University of medicine has opened in London, England for women, but many people around her don’t believe that women should do more than marry, have children, and run a household. Too much reading and learning can lead to insanity and mental illness. Due to a set of unfortunate circumstances the narrator in fact ends up in an insane asylum called Wildthorn. There she meets various patients, male figureheads on power trips, and a very kind nurse named Eliza. Without going too much into the actual meat of this story she tries to escape, make friends with patients, and figure out who did this to her and why. This is, as mentioned, revealed mostly through flashbacks that the narrator can’t fully comprehend, as she’s too deep and involved in it, and leaves the readers to speculate until the very end.

Addressing some of the other tags above, specifically LGBT+ and feminism. Yes, this is a LGBT+ and you should be made aware of that. If you’re not okay with romance between people of the same gender then please move along. I am not going to say anymore about this as it is quite a large portion of the book. It deals not only with women’s role in the victorian era, but how mental illness is treated. It talks a bit about fashion (always one of my loves), activities, food, and more, but it’s not a main focus. This book deals with heavy topics and one of the patients in the asylum could have been straight out of a Law and Order: Special Victims Unit episode.

The romance in the story is heart warming and at the same time heart wrenching. It feels you with joy only to watch it shattered. It takes you on a roller coaster as only true love can through the eyes of a relatively sheltered 17 year old who is suddenly faced with much more than she could have ever imagined. None the less, in the face of absolute despair she carries on and eventually preservers.

And now some quotes and a last fleeting image for your enjoyment.

Her bright face, emerging from a cloud of white satin and floating feathers, was like a flower on a slender neck.
Jane Eagland, Wildthorn (via cultivate-erudite)
Even in the gloom, her face was bright: she always seemed on the verge of speaking or laughing.
Jane Eagland, Wildthorn (via cultivate-erudite)
She had a new mysterious way of smiling, as if she knew things I didn’t. It made her look beautiful, like the princess in Hans Anderson’s story about the wild swans.
Jane Eagland, Wildthorn (via cultivate-erudite)
It’s totally dark. I’m numb with cold, and fear beats in my ears. I can’t move. A heavy weight is pinning me down. My mouth, my eyes, my ears are blocked with darkness. I’ve been buried alive. They have dug a pit and put me in it and stamped the earth down on top of me so that I can’t cry out…
Wildthorn : Jane Eagland  (via iamaplague)

tumblr_mqg1muZjwp1s5r0ogo7_250

Image courtesy of secretlesbians on tumblr. Footnote reads 19th century queer couples. This one in specific is dated to the 1900s. I believe it depicts the relationship perfectly.

As always all opinions and views noted above are my own. If you’re thinking about buying the book then check out other reviews.

Thank you for taking the time to read this,

~ Yoku

The Infernal Devices: Clockwork Angel Volume One – A Spoiler Free Review

tumblr_mpisxk5Rxc1sr4kueo1_1280

Infernal Devices collage (cover and main three characters) thanks to eternally-reading over on Tumblr.

Book: The Infernal Devices: Clockwork Angel Volume One

Author: Cassandra Clare

Artist: Hyekyung Baek

Age Group: Teen

Genre: Graphic Novel, Action, Adventure, Romance, Fantasy

Rating: 4.5/5

Keeping with my steampunk theme we jump right into The Infernal Devices: Clockwork Angel Volume One, an adaption of one of my favorite series by Cassandra Clare. Surprised it took me this long to pick up? I was never a fan of the art I’d seen of it around. This series was very close to me and my personal imagery of it. I was honestly worried it would be ruined by this graphic novel adaption. I’m here to say that each depiction might have not been exactly to my own personal image, but it was fun and pretty darn close.

I’m a huge fan of REM’s art style, so moving from that to Hyekyung Baek style was a little hard for me. I’ve also been a huge fan of Cassandra Jean’s art style, check her out, and she’s done multiple fan art pieces, so this new artist was harsh on my eyes. The front cover, I find now though, is a bit deceiving of the styling inside the cover. The actual style is pretty soft and smooth, the era based fashion and architecture is pretty spot on. I also love the way that she depicts Jem and Jessamine. The emotions expressed throughout the graphic novel are spot on, and the monster are just gruesome enough to make you cringe, but keep reading. The Silent Brothers made me shiver, as they should, and I can’t wait to see more of them throughout.

My biggest faults with the depiction is the over simplification. The Steles, Angel Blades, and tattoos are all super simplified and I feel like the artist cut corners here. This is also for not with the automans. This actually disappointed me quite a bit as some of my favorite artistic pieces from the series have extreme depictions of the tattoos, muscle definition, clothing, and so much more. I’d link one of my favorite ones at the bottom, but it is a tad risque for polite company. Instead I’ll link a couple other samples. Saying this though, the actual graphic novel has some spectacular splashes such as this one:

tumblr_lxx6kbo4qJ1qm09j5

I’ve come to conclude that I believe what turns me off is Baek’s use of color because the black and white splashes are quite stunning.

The dialogue and progression of action is spot-on with the novel and I believe that it stops at a perfectly ominous place. Overall, I highly recommend that fans check this adaption out. I’d love to see this as a TV series, mini-series, or maybe a movie adaption eventually.

As always all opinions and views noted above are my own. If you’re thinking about buying the book then check out other reviews.

Thank you for taking the time to read this,

~ Yoku

PS. One of the following pieces is in fact by Cassandra Jean, can you pick it out?

tumblr_mlx4t96lad1r3oy4vo1_1280 tumblr_mmcqr2qc811r3oy4vo1_1280will_x_tessa_by_smitth-d4jrd30 will_tessa_and_jem_sketch_by_kara_lija-d47u1c0 3427453844_ceab9319a9_z tessa_gray_by_miss_t_fy-d312gwa